Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission when you sign up for Patriot Software or Gusto through our links. This comes at no extra cost to you.

Payroll comparison 2026

Patriot is the low-sticker payroll pick and Gusto is the broader payroll, benefits, and HR stack. Which one wins depends on your headcount, your states, and whether you want benefits in the same place as payroll.

By Thomas Camp Jr., EA Updated November 2026 13 min read

The bottom line

If you only need payroll plus tax filings, Patriot Full Service is the default. Gusto is a broader platform you may not use. If your next hire is in a second state and you want time tracking included (Plus) or benefits administered with payroll, Gusto earns the premium. Do not compare Patriot Basic ($17 + $4) to Gusto without saying Basic leaves filings with you. Time tracking is an add-on on Gusto Simple; it is included on Plus.

Starting atPatriot Full Service $37 + $5 vs Gusto Simple $49 + $7
Watch outPatriot Basic does not file your taxes; Gusto Simple is one state only
Best forPatriot: payroll-and-taxes on a budget; Gusto: payroll, benefits, and HR
Key strengthPatriot: lowest Full Service sticker; Gusto: broader platform
Patriot Software

Patriot Software · 4.4 / 5

Full-service payroll with a clear file-it-yourself Basic tier

  • Full Service from $37/mo + $5 per worker paid
  • Free direct deposit
  • +$12/mo per extra state
  • Basic ($17 + $4) is file-it-yourself
See Patriot pricing
Gusto

Gusto · 4.5 / 5

Payroll, benefits, and HR all in one place

  • Simple from $49/mo + $7 per person
  • Multi-state on Plus ($99 + $12)
  • Health insurance administration included
  • Unlimited payrolls on every plan
See Gusto pricing

What Patriot and Gusto each are

Patriot Software is US payroll with two sticky products. Basic calculates taxes and leaves deposits and filings with you. Full Service adds federal, state, and local filing plus year-end forms (940, 941, W-2, W-3) with no extra filing fee. No software surcharge on direct deposit. Per Patriot's pricing page, checked November 9, 2026.

Gusto is US payroll with a Simple / Plus / Premium menu, plus Solo for owner payroll. Gusto's own line: payroll, benefits, and HR all in one place. Simple runs basic payroll in one state. Plus adds multi-state plus time tracking and scheduling. Health insurance administration is included; 401(k), workers' comp, HSA/FSA, and life/disability are add-ons. Per Gusto's pricing page, checked November 9, 2026.

At 10 people on regular rates, Patriot Full Service is $87/mo. Gusto Simple is $119/mo. Gusto Plus is $219/mo. Patriot wins on sticker and keeps winning when a second state only costs +$12/mo instead of the Plus jump.

I am an Enrolled Agent, not a CPA. Sourced sticker comparison, not a firsthand product test.

Patriot vs Gusto pricing (2026)

How we know the numbers. Patriot: pricing page, Pricing Transparency, and Help Center "What is the price of the software?", checked November 9, 2026 (live GET 200). Gusto: pricing page (gusto.com/product/pricing), checked November 9, 2026, 8:17 AM ET. Source note: Gusto pricing page, checked Nov 9, 2026.

Patriot plans (regular rates)

Basic Payroll

$17/mo

+$4 per worker paid

You deposit and file the taxes

  • Free direct deposit and employee portal
  • Unlimited payrolls, auto payroll
  • Pay contractors in payroll
  • Patriot calculates taxes; you file and deposit

Patriot defines "worker paid" as any employee or 1099 contractor paid at least once in the month, counted once. No run in a month means base fee only. Published examples: 5 workers Basic $37 / Full Service $62; 10 workers $57 / $87; 25 $117 / $162; 50 $217 / $287.

Promo footnote only. New accounts: 30 days free, then 50% off for 3 months. Table numbers are regular rates only.

Gusto plans

Simple

$49/mo

+$7 per person / month

5 people ≈ $84/mo · 10 people ≈ $119/mo

  • Run basic payroll in one state
  • Unlimited payrolls per month
  • Health insurance administration included
  • Time tracking is an add-on on Simple

Premium

$179/mo

+$22 per person / month

5 people ≈ $289/mo · 10 people ≈ $399/mo

  • Highest published Gusto tier here
  • Unlimited payrolls per month
  • Health insurance administration included
  • Confirm feature list on Gusto's pricing page

Gusto Solo and add-ons

Gusto Solo is $49/mo + $6 per person ($55 for one person by plain math), per Gusto's pricing page, checked Nov 9, 2026. Unlimited payrolls on every plan. Health insurance administration is included. 401(k), workers' comp, HSA/FSA, and life/disability are add-ons.

Sample monthly cost (regular rates)

People Patriot Basic Patriot Full Service Gusto Simple Gusto Plus Gusto Premium
5$37$62$84$159$289
10$57$87$119$219$399
25$117$162$224$399$729
50$217$287$349$680$1,280

Gusto = base + people × per-person (Gusto pricing page, checked Nov 20, 2026). Patriot counts workers paid in a month; Gusto bills per person on the published menu. At 10 people: Full Service vs Simple $32/mo; vs Plus $132/mo. Two-state: Patriot $99 vs Gusto Plus $219.

As of November 9, 2026 for Patriot and Gusto. Regular rates only; Patriot promo is temporary and not in the table.

Head-to-head: Patriot vs Gusto

Row Patriot Software Gusto
Base (full service peer)Full Service $37/moSimple $49 · Plus $99 · Premium $179
Per person / worker$5 per worker paid (Full Service); Basic $4$7 / $12 / $22 per person
10-person costFull Service $87 · Basic $57Simple $119 · Plus $219 · Premium $399
Tax filingFull Service only (Basic is DIY)Full-service payroll product (confirm filings on Gusto's page)
Multi-state+$12/mo per extra state on Full ServicePlus and Premium (plan jump, not a +$12 state line)
Unlimited runsYesYes (unlimited payrolls per month)
Direct depositFree (4-day standard; 2-day for qualifying customers)Included with payroll; speed tiers not restated here
BenefitsHealth benefits integrationHealth insurance administration included; 401(k), HSA/FSA, life/disability add-ons
HR toolsAdd-on HR Software $6/mo + $2 per W-2 employee paidHR in the same product family (see Gusto pricing page)
Time trackingAdd-on Time & Attendance $6/mo + $2 per W-2 using a time cardAdd-on on Simple; included on Plus
Best forPayroll + tax filings on a budgetPayroll, benefits, and HR all in one place

Gusto vs OnPay 2026 · Patriot vs OnPay 2026. OnPay named in plain text only.

Feature cards that change the pick

Tax filing and year-end

  • Patriot Full Service files federal, state, local, and year-end forms
  • Patriot Basic: you deposit and file
  • Gusto is sold as full-service payroll; confirm filing detail on its pricing page
  • DIY filing penalties stay with you

Multi-state

  • Patriot Full Service: +$12/mo per extra state
  • Gusto Simple: one state; multi-state on Plus
  • Worked example in the Multi-state section

Time tracking

  • Patriot: paid Time & Attendance add-on
  • Gusto Simple: time tracking is an add-on
  • Gusto Plus: time tracking and scheduling included

Benefits and health admin

  • Patriot: free health benefits integration
  • Gusto: health insurance administration included
  • Gusto add-ons: 401(k), workers' comp, HSA/FSA, life/disability

HR, contractors, and S-corp

  • Patriot HR add-on $6/mo + $2 per W-2; Experts $45/mo flat
  • Gusto: payroll, benefits, and HR all in one place
  • Both pay contractors inside payroll
  • Gusto Solo is $49/mo + $6 per person ($55 for one)

Multi-state math

Patriot Full Service includes one state. Each extra state is +$12/mo. Gusto Simple is one state ("run basic payroll in one state"). Multi-state needs Plus at $99 + $12 per person. At 10 people in two states, Patriot Full Service is $99/mo ($87 + $12). Gusto Plus is $219/mo. That is a $120/mo gap ($1,440/yr) before you price benefits or whether you need Plus for time tracking.

Payroll-only: Patriot Full Service keeps second-state math simple. Platform buy: price Gusto Plus as a platform, not pure payroll.

Money and liability notes from an EA

Basic vs Full Service liability

Patriot Basic leaves deposits and filings with you, including penalty risk. Full Service moves filings to Patriot. If an accountant already files, Basic can be rational. Otherwise Full Service is the peer to Gusto, not Basic.

One-person S-corp: Patriot Full Service for one worker paid is $37 + $5 = $42/mo. Gusto Solo is $49 + $6 = $55/mo for one person. Patriot is cheaper on paper. Pick Solo when you want Gusto's owner-payroll path, not because the sticker is lower.

At 25 and 50 people the sticker gap widens versus Patriot Full Service. Fine if you are buying benefits and HR. Expensive if you only need filings. Ask your EA whether they already work inside either stack.

Who wins which scenario

1-10 employees

One state, taxes only

Patriot Full Service. Filings without a benefits platform.

Multi-state

Remote hires across states

Patriot Full Service if you only need payroll and tax filing (+$12 per extra state). Gusto Plus if you also want time tracking and scheduling included with multi-state.

Benefits

Benefits-heavy team

Gusto. Health insurance administration is included; other benefits are add-ons.

S-corp

One-person S-corp salary

Patriot is cheaper on paper ($42 vs Solo $55). Gusto Solo is the owner-payroll path. Pick on tooling.

DIY taxes

Accountant already files

Patriot Basic, only if filings are truly covered elsewhere.

Pros and cons

Patriot

  • Full Service $37 + $5 is the lowest full-service sticker here.
  • Extra state is +$12/mo, not a forced plan jump.
  • Free direct deposit; unlimited payrolls.
  • Published 5 / 10 / 25 / 50 worker-paid examples.
  • Basic exists when an accountant already files.
  • HR and time tracking are optional add-ons.

Patriot tax

  • Basic leaves tax deposits and filings with you.
  • Benefits are integration, not full in-product admin.
  • HR and time tracking cost extra ($6 + $2 patterns).
  • No Solo-style owner-payroll packaging on the public menu.
  • Promo is temporary; do not budget on the 50% window.

Gusto

  • Unlimited payrolls on every plan, including Simple.
  • Payroll, benefits, and HR all in one place.
  • Health insurance administration included.
  • Time tracking and scheduling included on Plus.
  • Solo path at $49 + $6 per person.

Gusto tax

  • Sticker is higher than Patriot Full Service at every sample headcount in the table.
  • Simple is one state only. Multi-state forces the Plus jump ($99 + $12).
  • Time tracking is an add-on on Simple, not included.
  • 401(k), workers' comp, HSA/FSA, and life/disability are add-ons.

Final verdict

4.4
Patriot / 5 · Gusto 4.5

Patriot Full Service earns the default when the job is payroll plus tax filings on a budget. At 10 people that is $87/mo versus Gusto Simple at $119 or Plus at $219. Gusto earns the premium when you want payroll, benefits, and HR all in one place, multi-state with time tracking on Plus, or the Solo owner-payroll path.

Patriot is ideal if you

  • Need payroll plus tax filings without a benefits platform.
  • Add states one at a time for +$12/mo.
  • Have an accountant who can own Basic filings.

Gusto is ideal if you

  • Want payroll, benefits, and HR all in one place.
  • Need multi-state with time tracking included on Plus.
  • Want the Solo owner-payroll path.

Consider ADP (plain text) for quote-based enterprise depth, or OnPay (plain text) for a different mid-market shape. Stay on Patriot for the lowest Full Service sticker.

Pick your payroll, then run it

Patriot from $37/mo + $5 per worker (Full Service); Gusto from $49/mo + $7 per person.

Patriot Software

Full Service $37 + $5 per worker. Basic $17 + $4 if you file taxes yourself.

Get Patriot

Regular rates, Patriot pricing page, Nov 9, 2026. Promo is temporary.

Gusto

From $49/mo + $7 per person (Simple). Plus $99 + $12. Premium $179 + $22. Unlimited payrolls.

Get Gusto

Gusto pricing page, checked Nov 9, 2026. Route via /go/gusto/.

Frequently asked questions

Which is cheaper, Patriot or Gusto?

On regular rates at 10 people, Patriot Full Service is $87/mo. Gusto Simple is $119/mo and Plus is $219/mo. Patriot Basic is $57/mo, but you deposit and file the taxes yourself. Compare Full Service to Gusto, not Basic to Gusto, unless you are ready to own the filings.

What is the difference between Patriot Basic and Full Service?

Basic is $17 + $4: Patriot calculates taxes; you deposit and file. Full Service is $37 + $5: Patriot files and deposits federal, state, and local plus year-end forms. Full Service is the peer to Gusto.

Does Patriot file taxes?

Yes on Full Service. No on Basic. Basic leaves deposits and filings with you, including penalty risk.

Does Gusto include time tracking on every plan?

No. Time tracking is an add-on on Simple. Time tracking and scheduling are included on Plus. Do not assume Simple comes with a clock.

How does multi-state work on each?

Patriot Full Service: one state included, +$12/mo per extra state. Gusto: Simple is one state; Plus adds multi-state. There is no separate +$12 Gusto state line; you buy the higher plan.

Which is better for S-corp owners?

Price: Patriot Full Service for one worker is $42/mo. Gusto Solo is $55/mo for one person ($49 + $6). Feature fit: Solo is Gusto's owner-payroll path. Patriot is full-service payroll without that Solo packaging.

How are contractors billed?

Patriot counts employees and 1099s paid at least once in the month as workers paid. Confirm Gusto's current contractor billing on its pricing page before you model 1099-heavy months.

Do they charge per payroll run?

No extra per-run fee on the Patriot Basic / Full Service plans covered here. Gusto publishes unlimited payrolls per month on Simple, Plus, and Premium.

Can I cancel anytime?

Patriot lets you add or remove products; confirm cancellation timing on Patriot's terms before you buy. Confirm Gusto's current cancel terms on its pricing or help pages before you model lock-in.

Which has benefits and HR?

Gusto's line is payroll, benefits, and HR all in one place, with health insurance administration included and 401(k), workers' comp, HSA/FSA, and life/disability as add-ons. Patriot offers free health benefits integration plus paid HR and time add-ons.

Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission when you sign up for Patriot Software or Gusto through our links, at no extra cost to you. Patriot Software and Gusto and their logos are trademarks of their respective owners. Pricing and features accurate as of November 9, 2026 (Patriot and Gusto pricing pages checked live).

Thomas Camp Jr., EA

Written by

Thomas Camp Jr., EA

IRS-licensed Enrolled Agent

Enrolled Agent. Published Patriot and Gusto rates checked November 9, 2026. Verify EA credentials →