Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission when you sign up for Gusto, Patriot Software, OnPay, or ADP through our links. This comes at no extra cost to you.

Payroll comparison 2026

ADP doesn't publish a rate card for RUN, and that's why a lot of owners start shopping. Here's how Gusto, Patriot Software, and OnPay compare on published prices, tax filing, and multi-state payroll, and when I'd still get an ADP quote, as an Enrolled Agent.

By Thomas Camp Jr., EA Updated November 2026 14 min read

The short answer

If you're leaving ADP and want a price you can see before you sign, OnPay is the closest match, Patriot Full Service is the cheapest, and Gusto is the pick when you want benefits and HR in the same place. All three publish their rates and file your payroll taxes on the plans below. ADP is still worth a quote if you run several companies or you want ADP's HR bundle.

Starting atPatriot Full Service $37/mo + $5 per worker
Watch outADP is quote-only
Best forOwners leaving or comparing ADP
Key strengthThree alternatives with public prices
Patriot Software

Patriot Software · 4.8 / 5

Lowest full-service bill

  • Full Service $37 + $5 per worker
  • Extra state +$12/mo
  • Year-end filings included
See Patriot Software
Gusto

Gusto · 4.6 / 5

Payroll plus benefits and HR

  • Simple $49 + $7 per person
  • Multi-state on Plus
  • Month-to-month
See Gusto

Why people look for ADP alternatives

ADP is a big, capable payroll company, and RUN Powered by ADP handles the basics well. When owners tell me why they're shopping, it's rarely about whether payroll runs. It's about the bill.

No price until you talk to sales

ADP says plainly that it quotes RUN case by case. Its pricing page lists what moves the number: how many and what type of workers, pay frequency, payment methods, support level, and add-ons.

Extras that show up later

ADP's package page says W-2 and 1099 forms come with an additional fee, and extra payrolls cost more the more often you run them. Contractors are billed as their own bundle with a base price and a per-contractor fee.

A contract you didn't expect

ADP's package FAQ says RUN isn't a long-term contract and you can cancel anytime. ADP's pricing page also says that once you agree to a proposal, you'll be given a contract. Read it before you sign.

A quote that's hard to compare

When one provider publishes prices and the other quotes, owners can't easily tell whether they're paying a fair rate. That's the gap this article fills.

ADP alternatives compared (2026)

Published list prices, per each vendor's pricing page, checked November 13, 2026. Promotions are left out so you're comparing regular rates.

Feature OnPay Patriot Full Service Gusto ADP RUN
Base price$49/mo$37/moSimple $49, Plus $99, Premium $179Get a quote
Per-worker fee$6$5 per worker paid$7, $12, or $22 per personGet a quote
Payroll tax filingIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Multi-stateIncluded, all 50 states+$12/mo per extra statePlus and PremiumMulti-jurisdiction in every package
W-2s and 1099sIncludedYear-end filings includedIncludedAdditional fee
BillingMonthly, for workers paid the prior periodMonthly, in arrearsMonth-to-month, cancel any timeService contract after proposal

What three common team sizes cost

WorkersPatriot Full ServiceOnPayGusto SimpleGusto PlusADP
5$62/mo$79/mo$84/mo$159/moQuote
10$87/mo$109/mo$119/mo$219/moQuote
25$162/mo$199/mo$224/mo$399/moQuote

Gusto prices as of November 20, 2026; Patriot and OnPay as of November 13, 2026, at regular rates: base fee plus the per-worker fee times headcount. Gusto Simple covers one state. Patriot Full Service adds $12 a month for each additional state. Run your own numbers in the 2026 payroll software costs calculator.

Gusto as an ADP alternative

Gusto is the alternative most owners have already heard of. Per Gusto's pricing page, checked November 20, 2026, Simple is $49 a month plus $7 per person for payroll in one state, with unlimited payrolls and tax filings and payments. Plus is $99 plus $12 per person and adds multi-state payroll, time tracking and scheduling, and unlimited next-day pay. Premium is $179 plus $22 per person with Premium Account Support, HR guidance, and Gusto Business Compliance.

For an ADP customer, Gusto's appeal is the platform around payroll: health benefits, 401(k) plans, business insurance, and HR tools in one place, with a price you can see first. Gusto says it's month-to-month and you can cancel any time.

Where Gusto costs more than you'd expect: a team in more than one state. Multi-state starts on Plus, which is $219 a month at 10 people. Faster pay is also priced separately on Simple: next-day pay is $15 a month plus $3 per person, same-day pay is $90 per payroll, and instant pay is $100 per payroll.

For a direct matchup, see Gusto vs ADP. My full take is in the Gusto review and Gusto Pricing 2026.

Patriot Software as an ADP alternative

Patriot is the answer when the question is "How do I pay less and still have someone file for me?" Per Patriot's pricing page, checked November 13, 2026, Full Service Payroll is $37 a month plus $5 per worker paid. Patriot deposits and files federal, state, and local payroll taxes, includes year-end filings at no extra fee, and says tax filing reliability is guaranteed. At 10 workers that's $87 a month.

Patriot also sells Basic Payroll at $17 plus $4 per worker paid, but Basic only calculates the taxes. You deposit and file them yourself. If you're coming from ADP, where filing is part of every package, Basic isn't a fair swap. Stick with Full Service.

A few practical points for switchers. Patriot offers free payroll setup help and can enter your employees and year-to-date payroll for you. Support is US-based, 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. ET, Monday through Friday. Each additional state on Full Service is $12 a month. New customers currently get 30 days free plus 50% off for 3 months.

See my Patriot Software review, Patriot vs Gusto, and cheapest payroll for small business.

OnPay as an ADP alternative

OnPay is my top pick for an ADP customer who wants the same kind of all-in payroll with a visible price. There's one payroll plan. Per OnPay's pricing page, checked November 13, 2026, Payroll Essentials is $49 base plus $6 per worker per month, and your first month is free.

That plan covers W-2 and 1099 workers, unlimited pay runs, automatic federal, state, and local tax filings, W-2s and 1099s at year end, and multi-state payroll in all 50 states at no additional cost. ADP includes multi-jurisdiction payroll in every RUN package, so OnPay is the alternative that matches that without moving you to a higher tier. OnPay backs its filings with an error-free guarantee, and it migrates your data for free.

Two billing details from OnPay's help center: the $6 fee applies to every worker included in a pay run that month, even if their net pay is $0, and billing runs monthly. Add-ons are separate, including HR at $15 base plus $2 per worker and time tracking at $15 base plus $4 per worker.

See my OnPay review, Gusto vs OnPay, and Patriot vs OnPay.

ADP competitors for small business

If you search for ADP competitors, you'll get lists built for mid-size companies, global HR platforms, and even stock-pick questions. For a US small business running RUN, the competitors that matter are the ones that do the same job for the same size company: full-service payroll, tax filing, and year-end forms for a team of a few people up to a few dozen.

I kept this list to three tools that publish their prices, so you can put a real number next to your ADP invoice. Here's how I'd match them to the reason you're shopping:

  • "My ADP bill keeps creeping up." Patriot Full Service. It's the lowest published full-service price here.
  • "I have people in more than one state." OnPay. Multi-state is in the base plan, like ADP's multi-jurisdiction payroll.
  • "I want benefits and HR, not just payroll." Gusto. Payroll, benefits, and HR tools in one account.
  • "I'm a one-person S corp." Read ADP payroll for an S corp first, then compare Patriot Full Service at $42 a month for one worker with Gusto Solo.

Hiring outside the US is a different problem. If that's why you're looking past ADP, Deel vs Gusto vs ADP covers the global side.

When I would still get an ADP quote

Leaving isn't always the right call. ADP sells RUN Powered by ADP in four packages: Essential Payroll, Enhanced Payroll (ADP's most popular), Complete Payroll & HR+, and HR Pro Payroll & HR. Every package includes tax calculation, filing, deposit, and reconciliation, and ADP says that if it makes a tax filing error, it pays the resulting fines or penalties. Every package also includes 24/7 support, multi-jurisdiction payroll, multi-company management, and a general ledger export to QuickBooks, Xero, Wave, and Creative Solutions.

I'd get a current ADP quote before switching if you:

  • Run more than one company. Multi-company management is in every RUN package.
  • Use ADP's HR tools. Complete and HR Pro bundle HR support and, on HR Pro, workplace training and applicant tracking.
  • Are mid-year with a complicated setup. Several states, garnishments, or unusual pay items make a mid-year move harder.
  • Haven't asked for a better rate. ADP prices by quote, so ask for a new one. Then compare it to the table above.

More in my ADP payroll review and ADP vs QuickBooks Payroll.

Switching mid-year

You can leave ADP at any point in the year, but the timing changes how much cleanup you do. Quarter end is the natural break. A January start is the cleanest, because the new provider files the whole year.

A note from an EA

Before your last ADP payroll, download the year-to-date register for every employee and the quarterly returns already filed. Be clear in writing about who files the current quarter's 941 and the state returns, and who sends this year's W-2s. A lot of post-switch notices trace back to two providers each assuming the other one filed.

Patriot and OnPay both offer free help bringing over your employee and year-to-date data. Whichever you pick, run one parallel payroll and check it against your last ADP pay stub before you cancel. For more on choosing, see best payroll software for small business.

Pros and cons of leaving ADP

Pros

  • You can see the price before you sign up.
  • Full-service tax filing on every alternative plan covered here.
  • W-2s and 1099s included rather than billed extra.
  • Gusto is month-to-month, and OnPay and Patriot bill monthly for what you used.

Cons

  • A mid-year switch means YTD data transfer and a clear handoff on filings.
  • Gusto's multi-state payroll needs the Plus plan.
  • Patriot charges $12 a month for each extra state.
  • You lose ADP's multi-company tools if you run several entities.

Final verdict: the best ADP alternative

4.8
out of 5 · OnPay, same house score as our OnPay review

OnPay is the ADP alternative I'd start with. One plan, multi-state included, filings and year-end forms in the price, and $109 a month at 10 workers. If you're in one state and want the lowest full-service bill, choose Patriot Full Service at $87. If you want benefits and HR in the same place, choose Gusto. If you run several companies, get a fresh ADP quote before you move.

Switch from ADP if you

  • Want a published price you can check every year.
  • Pay extra today for W-2s, 1099s, or off-cycle runs.
  • Run one company with a straightforward payroll.

Stay with ADP if you

  • Run several companies and use multi-company management.
  • Rely on ADP's HR bundle.
  • Got a new quote that beats the table above.

Compare your ADP bill

Each button takes you to the vendor for current pricing or a quote.

OnPay

$49 base + $6 per worker, multi-state included.

See OnPay

Patriot Software

Full Service from $37/mo + $5 per worker paid.

See Patriot Software

Gusto

Simple from $49/mo + $7 per person.

See Gusto

ADP

RUN packages, priced by quote.

Get an ADP quote

Gusto prices as of November 20, 2026; other list prices from each vendor's pricing page, November 13, 2026.

ADP alternatives FAQ

What are the different ADP products for small business?

For small businesses, ADP sells RUN Powered by ADP in four packages: Essential Payroll, Enhanced Payroll, Complete Payroll & HR+, and HR Pro Payroll & HR. Each step up adds more HR support.

Why doesn't ADP show a price online?

ADP says it quotes RUN based on your business: the number and type of workers, pay frequency, payment methods, support level, and add-ons. It doesn't publish a rate card.

How much are Gusto, Patriot, and OnPay for 10 people?

At regular rates: Patriot Full Service $87 a month, OnPay $109, Gusto Simple $119 for one state, and Gusto Plus $219. Gusto prices checked November 20, 2026; Patriot and OnPay as of November 13, 2026.

Does leaving ADP mean I lose tax filing?

No. OnPay, Gusto, and Patriot Full Service all deposit and file your payroll taxes. Patriot Basic doesn't, so pick Full Service if you want filing handled.

Can these alternatives run multi-state payroll?

Yes. OnPay includes all 50 states in its base price. Gusto includes multi-state on Plus and Premium. Patriot Full Service charges $12 a month for each additional state.

Do I have to sign a long-term ADP contract?

ADP's package FAQ says RUN isn't a long-term contract and you can cancel at any time. ADP also says you'll receive a contract once you agree to a proposal, so read the cancellation terms in that document.

Will my accountant be able to get in?

Yes. OnPay has outside collaborator permissions for accountants and bookkeepers, and Gusto says owners can give their accountant direct access. Patriot runs a partner program for accounting firms. See best payroll software for accountants.

Is there a cheaper ADP alternative?

Of the three here, Patriot Full Service has the lowest published full-service price: $37 a month plus $5 per worker paid, or $87 at 10 workers.

Who are ADP's main competitors for small business?

For a US small business, the closest competitors to RUN are full-service payroll providers like Gusto, OnPay, and Patriot Software. If you're leaving Gusto instead, see Gusto alternatives.

Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission when you sign up for Gusto, Patriot Software, OnPay, or ADP through our links. This comes at no extra cost to you and helps support our independent research and reviews. ADP, RUN Powered by ADP, Gusto, Patriot Software, OnPay, and their logos are trademarks of their respective owners. Gusto prices as of November 20, 2026; other list prices as of November 13, 2026.

Thomas Camp Jr., EA

Written by

Thomas Camp Jr., EA

IRS-licensed Enrolled Agent

I advise small businesses on payroll and taxes, and I answer the notices when a payroll switch goes wrong. I read a pricing page the way I read a tax notice: dollars first, then the fine print. Verify EA credentials →